Five ways to spot fake followers on Instagram
Scrolling through an Instagram profile, you might be impressed by a huge follower count.
But does a big number always mean big influence?
Not necessarily. And the data backs this up.
Research shows that fake followers and bogus engagement remain a widespread issue; skewing how influence is measured and making it harder for brands to identify real and ROI.
So, whether you're a brand considering a partnership or just curious about the authenticity of a profile, spotting fake followers is a crucial skill.
Here are five key approaches to help you reveal the truth!
1. How to spot fake influencers using Engagement Rate
Research estimates that up to 55% of Instagram engagement may be fake, driven by bots and engagement pods.
Followers mean very little unless they actually interact. One of the fastest ways to spot fake followers is to compare a profile’s engagement to its follower count. For example, an account with 100,000 followers but only a few hundred likes or comments per post is a clear red flag.
Engagement rate is calculated by dividing total likes and comments by the number of followers, then multiplying by 100. For genuine accounts, average Instagram engagement typically falls between 1% and 5%, depending on niche and audience size.
As Stack Influence notes: “If an influencer’s engagement rate is under ~1%, it often indicates low or inauthentic interaction.”
Rates well below this often suggest inactive or fake followers.
It’s also important to look beyond the numbers. Some accounts use bots to inflate likes and comments, but this activity often looks unnatural. Fake engagement tends to appear as:
Generic comments
Repetitive emojis
Identical phrases used across posts.
Timing can be another giveaway. Sudden spikes in likes or comments immediately after posting may indicate automated activity, whereas authentic engagement usually builds gradually as real followers discover and interact with the content.
Finally, assess comment quality. Genuine followers ask questions, share personal experiences, or reference specific details from the post. Fake accounts typically rely on vague praise or spam-like remarks. Examining these interaction patterns helps reveal whether a profile’s audience is truly engaged—or largely artificial.
2. Real vs fake Instagram followers: Red flags to look out for
Academic research estimates that around 10% of Instagram’s 2.4 billion accounts are fake.
Digging into the profiles of followers is therefore worth the time investment, and can reveal a lot:
Common fake follower traits:
No profile photo or bio
Very few posts (or none at all)
Usernames with random numbers/letters
Following thousands of accounts but having very few followers.
In fact, a 2025 investigation found that nearly 49% of Instagram influencers have used fake followers at some point.
While authentic Instagram accounts tend to have consistent posting habits and varied interactions spread across different platforms, fake accounts often have no engagement metrics to show at all.
This lack of evidence can be another red flag, indicating that the account is inflating its follower count without building a real community.
By taking a closer look into all of these aspects, you can better establish the authenticity of an account's follower base. All of this extra work helps to ensure that your engagement efforts are directed toward a real audience rather than accounts that are actually Instagram ghosts.
3. Spotting fake followers by focusing on growth trends
Organic follower growth tends to be steady and gradual.
Sudden spikes in follower count can be a sign that fake followers have been purchased or added artificially. If an account jumps from 10,000 to 50,000 followers overnight, that’s suspicious.
Use tools or even simple observation to track follower growth over time. Consistent growth with occasional dips or plateaus is normal… but rapid, unexplained surges often mean the account owner is trying to trick the system.
Legitimate viral moments usually come with increased engagement, media mentions, and widespread sharing.
4. How comment quality reveals fake engagement
Comments can be a goldmine for spotting fake followers, and they can often reveal more than looking at follower counts.
Red flags to watch out for:
Repetitive comments across multiple posts
Irrelevant or vague praise
Emoji-only replies posted in clusters.
Bots and fake accounts tend to leave generic or irrelevant comments like “Nice pic!”, “Awesome!”, or a trail of emojis.
These cookie-cutter responses not only dilute the authenticity of the engagement but also suggest that the account owner may have resorted to artificial means to inflate their follower count.
Real followers engage with content in a meaningful way. They ask questions, tag friends, or share personal opinions. If the comment section looks like a spam fest, it’s a sign that the account might have a fake audience.
5. How to use analytics tools to spot fake followers
Brands using influencer analytics tools report better ROI and reduced exposure to fraud.
Manual checks help, but tools speed things up.
Specialised tools can help you identify fake followers quickly. Commonly used platforms include HypeAuditor, Modash, and Social Blade, which analyse:
Audience authenticity
Engagement patterns
Suspicious follower behaviour.
Each of these tools employs sophisticated algorithms that sift through vast amounts of data; allowing users to pinpoint anomalies that may indicate inauthentic accounts.
Many of these tools offer free basic reports with paid options for deeper analysis, and using them regularly can help brands and influencers maintain transparency and trust.
Additionally, some tools allow users to track changes over time, enabling them to see how follower quality evolves after implementing specific strategies. This ongoing analysis can be invaluable for adjusting content and engagement tactics to attract a more authentic audience.
No tool is perfect, but combining software data with human review is best practice.
Protect brand reputation and your resources
Fake followers don’t just inflate numbers-they hurt credibility and waste precious resources, including your marketing budget.
Understanding how to spot fake followers helps you make smarter decisions. By paying attention to engagement rates, follower profiles, growth patterns, comment quality, and by harnessing analytical tools, you can separate real influence from smoke and mirrors.
So, next time you check out an Instagram profile, don’t be dazzled by the numbers. Look deeper for the truth.
=====
Now that you’ve read this, you may be interested in:
